Chapter 5: The Nurse's Diary
The rain against the windshield of my rental sedan sounded like scattered gravel as I pulled up to the curb of a fading brick apartment complex on the far west side of Chicago. The neighborhood was a far cry from the glittering high-rises of the Gold Coast where Evelyn spent her afternoons browsing designer boutiques. Here, the sidewalks were cracked, maple leaves clogged the iron storm drains, and the streetlights flickered with a dull, yellow amber.
I checked the slip of paper in my hand for the third time. Apartment 4B. The name on the buzzing directory had worn away years ago, leaving only a rectangular shadow in the brushed aluminum.
My heart hammered against my ribs, a dull, heavy thud that matched the steady downpour. Three days had passed since Julian and I parted ways outside the Grandview Ballroom. Three days since I had been thrown out by security, branded as unstable, dismissed as a disgruntled employee with a grudge. But the bruising on my cheek had faded to a sickly yellow-green, and my resolve had only hardened. Julian was still living under the same roof as a woman who had orchestrated at least one murder and attempted a second. If I didn't move quickly, he might become another footnote in a coroner's log.
I pressed the buzzer for 4B. A harsh, electronic squawk echoed through the lobby, followed by a woman’s raspy voice crackling through the intercom.
"Who is it? If it's another flyer for cable, I'm calling the landlord."
"Mrs. Gable?" I spoke clearly into the metal grille, keeping my voice steady. "My name is Clara Hayes. I used to work for Arthur Pendelton. I need to talk to you about his final months."
A heavy silence hung over the intercom. The rain beat harder against the glass canopy above the entrance. For a terrifying second, I thought the line would go dead, that the old woman would retreat deeper into her apartment and bolt the deadbolts.
Then, with a loud metallic click, the front door unlatched.
I pushed through the heavy glass door, smelling damp wool, bleach, and decades of old cigarette smoke in the stairwell. I climbed the four flights of concrete stairs, my boots echoing in the hollow well, until I reached a door standing half-open at the end of the dim hallway. A frail woman with sharp gray eyes and silver hair pulled back into a messy bun peered out at me through the gap, a heavy brass chain still holding the door securely in place.
"You said Arthur Pendelton?" she asked, her gaze sweeping over my simple trench coat and plain canvas bag. "The police interviewed me three years ago. I told them everything I knew. The man had a weak heart. It gave out. End of story."
"The police didn't know what Evelyn was slipping into his evening tonic," I said softly, stepping closer to the gap in the door. "And they didn't know she was the sole beneficiary of an offshore trust that liquidated forty-eight hours after his funeral."
Mrs. Gable’s eyes narrowed. She studied my face, looking past my eyes down to the faint, healing discoloration along my cheekbone. Something in her expression shifted—recognition, perhaps, or the heavy burden of a secret she had carried too long out of fear. With a dry clink, she lifted the chain off the latch and pushed the door wide open.
"Come inside before the draft freezes us both," she muttered, shuffling back into a small, cluttered living room overflowing with stacks of newspapers, knitted blankets, and the soft amber glow of a single floor lamp.
The apartment smelled of peppermint tea and old paper. She motioned me to a worn floral armchair while she lowered herself gingerly onto a sagging sofa opposite me. Her hands, spotted with age and gnarled by arthritis, trembled slightly as she smoothed the fabric of her cardigan.
"I was his private day nurse for four years," Mrs. Gable began without preamble, her voice raspy from a lifetime of speaking her mind. "Arthur was a good man. Quiet, generous, but terribly lonely after his first stroke. Then Evelyn walked into his office downtown. A twenty-five-year-old secretary with expensive tastes and eyes like chipped glass. Within six months, they were married. Within a year, he was dead."
"The death certificate said myocardial infarction," I reminded her, leaning forward, resting my elbows on my knees.
"The death certificate said what Evelyn paid the attending physician to write," Mrs. Gable snapped, her eyes flashing with sudden, sharp anger. "Arthur didn't have heart attacks like that. His cardiology reports from the Mayo Clinic six months prior showed a strong, stable heart. But right before he died, he started complaining of a strange metallic taste in his tea. He said his fingers went numb every time Evelyn brought him his evening glass of digitalis."
"Digitalis," I whispered. The word hung in the damp air like a physical weight.
"Digitalis glycosides," Mrs. Gable corrected, reaching down to lift a battered leather-bound journal from the floor beside her. She clutched it to her chest like a shield before holding it out toward me. "Arthur kept a personal log of his medication because he didn't trust pharmacies. And I kept a nursing journal because I knew something was wrong the night he passed. Evelyn was standing right there by his bedside, smiling while the paramedics tried to shock a heart that had been chemically arrested."
I took the journal from her trembling hands. The pages were yellowed, filled with neat, meticulous handwriting detailing dates, dosages, and observations about Evelyn's sudden, chilling interest in his estate planning.
"Why didn't you go public with this?" I asked, looking up into the old nurse's tired eyes. "Why keep this hidden in a drawer?"
Mrs. Gable let out a bitter, hollow laugh. "Go public? With what proof? Evelyn had the lawyers, the police chief in her pocket, and a battery of high-priced character witnesses who swore I was losing my mind to senility. They threatened to strip my pension and sue me into bankruptcy. I was old, Ms. Hayes. I wanted to live out my remaining years without ending up in an alley myself."
She leaned forward, her gaze piercing right through me. "But you... you look like someone who isn't planning on running away."
"I'm not," I said, slipping the journal carefully into my canvas bag. "I'm going to finish what Arthur started."
May you like
"Be careful, child," the old nurse whispered as I stood up to leave. "Evelyn doesn't leave loose ends. If she missed Julian at the reception, she'll try again. Men like that are just stepping stones until they become liabilities."
I thanked her, zipped my bag tightly, and stepped back out into the cold Chicago rain, carrying the hard, undeniable proof of a killer's blueprint.
