Chapter 13: The Deposition Room
The federal building on Clark Street smelled of floor wax, old paper, and institutional anxiety. The deposition room on the fourth floor was windowless, paneled in dark, utilitarian mahogany that looked like it had been salvaged from a 1970s government office. Fluorescent panels hummed overhead, casting a harsh, flat light across the scarred laminate table.
I sat at one end of the table, wearing a simple navy blazer and white blouse, my hands resting calmly over my belly. To my right sat Mark in his dark suit, acting as my informal counsel alongside AUSA Vance. Across the table sat Julian’s lead attorney, Marcus Vance—a silver-haired litigator known for his ruthless cross-examinations in high-net-worth divorce and corporate fraud cases.
Julian himself was not present; federal marshals kept him in a holding facility downtown, denying his request to attend civil depositions. But Elena was there, sitting in the corner of the room behind her legal team, wearing a tailored cream dress that looked desperately out of place under the harsh fluorescent lights. Her fingers twisted nervously around a silver fountain pen, her eyes darting toward me with a mixture of simmering resentment and thinly veiled panic.
"Let the record show that the witness is present and the deposition of Clara Vance is officially commencing," the court reporter droned monotonously from the corner, her fingers flying across her stenotype machine.
Marcus Vance leaned forward, resting his forearms on the table. He flashed a practiced, paternal smile that didn't reach his cold blue eyes. "Good morning, Clara. Let's talk about the evening of October twelfth. You've claimed in your affidavit that my client, Elena Vance, deliberately pushed you toward the edge of the upper gallery."
"She didn't push me with her hands," I replied evenly, my voice cutting cleanly through the hum of the overhead lights. I kept my tone level, refusing to give him the emotional outburst his team had prepared for. "She stepped directly into my path, blocked the exit to the stairs, and lunged forward as I tried to turn away. The physical momentum and her verbal threats caused the fall."
"A subtle distinction, isn't it?" Marcus scoffed, shuffling a sheaf of papers. "You were under considerable psychological stress at the time. You had discovered discrepancies in the Vance Foundation accounts earlier that evening. Isn't it true, Clara, that you tripped over your own hemline while in a state of acute emotional agitation?"
Across the table, Mark shifted slightly, his gaze locking onto the defense attorney with a quiet, menacing stillness that made Marcus hesitate for a fraction of a second.
"I was calm," I said quietly. "And I was holding my phone, recording the conversation because Julian had threatened to cut off my medical access if I exposed the foundation transfers. The audio log captures Elena's exact words: 'I swear I didn't want this! She rushed toward me, I only tried to stop her!' People who are simply standing out of the way don't shout apologies before the victim even hits the bottom of the marble staircase."
Elena flinched at the mention of the recording, her head snapping toward her lawyer as if urging him to change tactics.
Marcus cleared his throat, his paternal facade slipping away to reveal the sharp corporate shark underneath. "We have expert medical testimony indicating that your pregnancy hormone levels at the time could have caused dizziness and disorientation. We can prove—"
"You can't prove a biological fiction," AUSA Vance interrupted smoothly, sliding a certified hospital toxicology and neurology report across the table. "Every test administered at Chicago Memorial Hospital confirmed zero impairment, zero cognitive disruption, and physical trauma entirely consistent with a high-velocity descent down fifteen marble steps caused by an external obstruction."
The room fell dead silent. The only sound was the low, steady hum of the air conditioning unit. Marcus picked up the medical report, his eyes scanning the lines of diagnostic data with visible frustration. He knew as well as I did that the physical evidence was airtight.
"We reserve the right to recall the witness," Marcus muttered, slamming the folder shut with a dry thud. "This deposition is concluded for today."
As the defense attorneys began packing their briefcases, Elena stood up abruptly, her chair scraping loudly against the linoleum floor. She looked across the table at me, her mask of elegant composure entirely shattered. Her chest rose and fell in shallow, rapid breaths.
"You think you've won everything, don't you?" Elena hissed, taking a step toward the table before her lawyer grabbed her arm and pulled her back. "You came into our family with nothing—a nobody from a working-class suburb—and you think a foundation title makes you one of us?"
I didn't flinch, nor did I raise my voice. I simply looked up at her, seeing not the terrifying adversary from the mansion balcony, but a cornered woman whose entire world had been built on sand.
May you like
"I never wanted to be one of you, Elena," I said softly, resting my hand on my belly. "I just wanted to survive you. And now, I'm going to watch you explain to a federal judge where the eighty million dollars went."
Mark stood up, placing a firm, protective hand on my shoulder, and guided me toward the door. Behind us, the court reporter continued typing the final words of the record into her machine, sealing the truth into the permanent archives of the federal court.
